These things are amazing! No, seriously. We have a 9 week old golden retriever who wants to bite EVERYTHING, including fingers, toes, arms, etc. These glorified “cheese sticks” are nothing to look at, they’re not fancy, don’t smell of bacon, and aren’t squishy or squeak. BUT, they’ve already provided literal HOURS of valuable chew time for our pup. She will work at it for an hour straight, get tired and then take a nap. They’re a little messy, cuz they kinda give off little pieces of cheese when they’re being chewed, but that’s a small price to pay for endless hours of puppy entertainment. They might seem pricey, but they seem to last forever. I can’t say enough about these. I’ll be back for more if she ever gets through the 3-pack!! ( Himalayan Dog Chew)